Seven Montreal police officers have been fired in connection with the allegations of racism, discrimination and misconduct that have rocked the force for several months now.
Montreal police Chief Fady Dagher called it an “exceptional measure” and a first in the force’s history.
“As we moved forward, it became increasingly clear to me that, in terms of building trust with the public, we needed to reach a different level,” Dagher told a Monday afternoon press conference. “It’s all well and good to talk about criminal matters or professional ethics, but what immediate action could be taken in relation to these individuals?
“By administratively dismissing these individuals, we can provide assurance that they will no longer wear the uniform, nor will they carry a weapon or continue to serve the citizens of Montreal. I believe this sends a very, very clear message — to the outside world, to our partners, and to the victims.”
Five of the officers previously worked at Station 39 in Montreal North, the precinct that saw a 16-officer team disbanded over the summer following claims that officers cut locks of hair from racialized citizens to keep as “trophies.”
Two of the officers worked at Station 21 in downtown Montreal — one linked to an allegation of racism, the other linked to an allegation of a discriminatory act involving a vulnerable person. Dagher acknowledged media reports that claimed an officer from Station 21 urinated on a homeless person, but said that “does not correspond to anything in our internal investigations.”
“We do have a case involving a police officer who committed a despicable act — an act of a similar nature, but not one directed at a human being. Let me be very, very clear: the SPVM is not investigating this particular allegation.”
Six of the seven officers were previously suspended, with the file having been sent to Quebec’s Crown prosecution office to determine if criminal charges would be forthcoming.
“Regarding the criminal aspect, that process is underway; we are waiting for the DPCP (Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions) to make a determination. I cannot predict what their decision will be,” the SPVM chief said.
A report also surfaced last week that a police officer from Station 39 erased video evidence from a victim of domestic violence. The officer involved in that allegation was reassigned to administrative duties last week, but it’s unclear if they are one of the officers who were fired.
Dagher, who described the firings as “administrative,” said they came after multiple meetings to review their accreditations regarding their “good character and conduct.”
“And when I reviewed all the evaluations — the assessment grids prepared by the investigators in consultation with the city’s lawyers — it became clear that they were no longer able to pass the safety protocol tests,” Dagher explained. “That is when their accreditation was revoked. Once that accreditation certificate is withdrawn, it means you are no longer employed by the city.”
Montreal Mayor Soraya Martinez Ferrada praised the decision in a brief statement to CityNews.
“The SPVM has taken an unprecedented step toward rebuilding public trust. No one is above the rules. This work is demanding and necessary, and it must continue,” the mayor said.
Fo Niemi, the executive director of the Center for Research-Action on Race Relations (CRARR), hopes this sets a precedent.
“I’ve never heard of police officers being fired for police misconduct, police racist misconduct,” Niemi said.
“For a police chief to act as firmly as decisively and as such an authoritative manner, I think it’s encouraging.”
Niemi says the firings send a signal to officers and Montrealers that “racism, misconduct, bias, abuse of police powers and authority — this is not tolerable anymore.”
The Red Coalition, a Montreal group dedicated to fighting systemic racism and racial profiling, is demanding the city launch an independent public inquiry into the SPVM.
‘Merely the baseline’
Dagher says the officers at the centre of all the allegations are a very small minority on the police force, and the chief spent a large part of Monday’s press conference praising the SPVM’s recent crime-fighting successes.
“What is the culture of the SPVM’s 99 per cent? It is a culture of respect, integrity, and commitment; a culture of excellence and courage; and a culture of mutual aid, service, and assisting others,” Dagher said.
That’s not good enough, says the leader of the Opposition at city hall, who believes firing the officers “does not address the root of the issue.”
“Since Friday, Mr. Dagher has repeatedly stated that only one per cent of police officers ‘tarnish the uniform.’ But when people call 911, they don’t want to be playing the lottery,” said Ericka Alneus, the leader of Projet Montréal, whose emergency motion to have Dagher appear before city council was rejected by the mayor last month.
“Mayor Soraya Martinez Ferrada must agree to urgently summon Fady Dagher before the city council, as requested by Projet Montréal. Dismissing officers who commit violent or reprehensible acts was necessary, but that is merely the baseline. It will take much more than that to even begin rebuilding the bond of trust between Montrealers and the SPVM.”
CityNews reached out to the Police Brotherhood, which said it would not be commenting on the dismissals.
–With files from Lola Kalder




