Faced with an increasingly inaccessible and costly justice system, the Barreau du Québec is proposing solutions, including an 811-type legal information line and a refundable tax credit for legal fees in family matters.
The organization representing lawyers released a report on Wednesday to “build the justice of tomorrow,” as its title says, and to present proposals to the new Minister of Justice, Marie-Claude Sarrazin.
The legal 811 service could be a model combining a telephone line, but also a chat service and digital guidance tools.
A tax credit would also make justice more accessible to the middle class, who are not entitled to legal aid.
Measures such as a tax credit or a telephone or chat service have a cost, which is not quantified by the report.
But, in the opinion of the Barreau du Québec president, Marcel-Olivier Nadeau, “there is also a cost to doing nothing, a cost to citizens abandoning justice, a cost of psychological distress.”
The report obtained by The Canadian Press argues, among other things, for “putting humans back at the heart of the justice system.”
A challenging system
People who have had to resort to the justice system have shared their experiences in interviews with The Canadian Press, describing the many hardships they have faced.
A woman, who was represented by a lawyer from the age of five because of the violence her father inflicted on her mother, had to go through the Criminal Chamber, the Civil Chamber and the Youth Chamber at the Court of Quebec.
This woman, who requested anonymity, concluded that lawyers lack training for this type of case and that they think they are protecting children, but they do not listen to them.
A man, who had to represent himself in Quebec Court for a hidden defect case, indicated that he had not been taken seriously by a lawyer.
He believes that “the justice system does not fix anything.”
He describes a system that is “very intimidating”, with “inaccessible” language that “makes us feel like idiots”.
In an interview with The Canadian Press, the president of the bar association acknowledged that “human support needs to be improved” because “people feel lost, alone, and powerless.”
Nadeau explained that the round of consultations last spring which led to this report aimed, among other things, to “give a face to the data and findings”.
The question of fees
Another participant in the consultations was caught up in a custody battle with her ex-partner over her children and the choice of school.
She recounted that she was initially entitled to a legal aid lawyer, but three times she had to change lawyers because he left to go and work in a more lucrative firm.
She finally resigned herself to hiring a lawyer in private practice and, even though the bill had been agreed upon, it skyrocketed.
The Barreau du Québec President argues that lawyers must be able to discuss fees “frankly” and he advocates for more transparency and predictability.
Furthermore, he calls for a “simplification” of civil and family law procedures, to avoid costly “procedural red tape”.
Nadeau is hopeful that the new Minister of Justice will welcome the Bar Association’s report.
“She knows that justice needs love and to be humanized,” he concluded.
The report is the result of a broad tour of regional consultations conducted by the Bar Association last spring.
A dozen forums were held across the country.
No less than 450 members of the Bar, the judiciary and organizations related to the administration of justice participated, as well as 45 people who have had an experience with the justice system.
–This report by La Presse Canadienne was translated by CityNews




