Competition Bureau ‘aware’ of Québecor’s $31B offer to acquire Telus

Québecor said Monday it has sent an unsolicited offer to acquire Telus in a merger deal valued at approximately $31 billion, which represents an enhanced proposal from June.

Telus confirmed on Monday it received the offer from Québecor on Nov. 9, and is conducting a “thorough review,” but there remain concerns about regulatory approvals potentially delaying such a merger.

“With the support of our advisors, the Special Committee is conducting a thorough review of Québecor’s proposal to determine the course of action that will be in the best interests of TELUS and its stakeholders,” said John Manley, Chair of the TELUS board of directors in a press release.

The proposed merger is expected to face scrutiny from regulators because of the perceived risk that it could lead to less choice in the telecommunications space and potentially higher prices for consumers.

Story continues below advertisement

Canada’s Competition Bureau confirmed to Global News in a statement that it’s “aware of the announcements from Quebecor and Telus.”

“The Bureau’s mandate is to review mergers to determine whether they harm competition. Under the Competition Act, we may review any merger or acquisition to protect and promote competition in Canada,” said the Competition Bureau.

“When a Bureau merger investigation determines that a transaction is likely to harm competition, we take appropriate action.”

The federal government said Monday it has “taken note of Quebecor’s proposal” and the proposed merger will be “rigorously reviewed” by the Competition Bureau and the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC).

“Connectivity is critical to Canada’s economy, sovereignty and national security, and to the daily lives of Canadians. Access to reliable, resilient high-performance networks, at prices Canadians can afford, is fundamental to the social and economic fabric of our country,” said Industry Minister Mélanie Joly in a statement.

“In the face of accelerating technological change, global instability and ongoing cost-of-living pressures, the Government of Canada will relentlessly prioritize the best interests of Canadians and Canadian sovereignty.”

Global News also sent a request for comment to the CRTC on Monday. A response is pending as of publication.


Click to play video: 'Québecor proposes $31B deal to buy Telus'


Québecor proposes $31B deal to buy Telus


Telus revealed in its press release that the proposal from last week represents an enhanced offer from a private offer Québecor made in June. Manley highlighted that the potential merger still carries significant risk, which was a concern with the initial proposal.

Story continues below advertisement

“To date, this review has surfaced a number of significant risks associated with Québecor’s proposal, including the fact that more than four months after its initial proposal, Québecor has yet to explain how what it is proposing could be approved under the current telecom regulatory framework in Canada and that a regulatory review of such a transaction would be a long and costly process for our shareholders,” said Manley.

Get daily Canada news delivered to your inbox so you'll never miss the day's top stories.

Get daily National news

Get daily Canada news delivered to your inbox so you’ll never miss the day’s top stories.

The risks Telus highlighted revolve mainly around expected regulatory hurdles, which Telus says Québecor’s offer fails to outline in a clear strategy.

“Québecor’s proposal does not set out the regulatory strategy Québecor would pursue, nor the remedies it would be prepared to accept to obtain those approvals,” said Telus in the release.

“Existing spectrum policy, the conditions on which recent wireless consolidation was approved, and amendments to the Competition Act give rise to significant concerns regarding the timing, conditions and overall uncertainty associated with obtaining the required regulatory approvals.”

“As presented, Québecor’s proposal does not appropriately allocate these risks between the parties.”

Telus also says that while its special committee discusses Québecor’s proposal it will also consider “strategic alternatives” to maximize value for its shareholders.

Québecor said in its own press release Monday that the two companies decided to make the merger discussions public given what’s at stake.

Story continues below advertisement

“Québecor continues to favour constructive dialogue with the TELUS Board of Directors and respects the review it is conducting. However, Québecor believes it is in the public interest to make its proposal known at this time,” said Québecor in its release.

“The telecommunications sector is undergoing profound change, and the proposed combination has implications beyond the purely financial realm: it directly affects consumers, business customers, employees, communities and the shareholders of both companies.”

Québecor also acknowledged in its release that it plans to “collaborate closely” with regulatory and government bodies through the approval process.

“Quebecor believes that this combination will serve the public interest. It is aware that the transaction will be subject to approval by the relevant authorities, including the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and ISED for the transfer of spectrum licenses,” said Québecor.

“Competition experts have been retained to assess the proposed combination and the issues that may be raised by public and regulatory authorities, including consideration of appropriate commitments, if necessary.”


Click to play video: '‘I’m not holding my breath’: Rogers-Shaw deal may not lower prices, economists say'


‘I’m not holding my breath’: Rogers-Shaw deal may not lower prices, economists say



How will this impact consumers?

For most Canadians, there are four main choices for telecommunications service providers — Rogers, Bell, Telus and Quebecor.

Story continues below advertisement

If this proposed merger crosses the finish line, it may turn four companies into three, and less competition in almost any sector typically leads to higher prices for consumers.

“PIAC is concerned about the impact on consumers in terms of prices and affordability, competition and the future of the telecommunications sector if this proposed takeover was to go ahead,” says Tahira Dawood, acting general counsel at the Public Interest Advocacy Centre (PIAC).

“If we are reducing the number of competitors in the market, it doesn’t just affect that specific region, it is possible that other service providers have less pressure in order to compete on price, compete on quality of service in other various aspects of your service.”

According to Québecor’s statement, the proposed merger “will benefit Canadian consumers through more choice, investment and value.”

Economics professor Moshe Lander at Concordia University says, in theory, there may be some truth to this merger opening the door for lower prices.

“If they were allowed to merge together, then you really only need one network that you would have to maintain. […] That would lower your average cost and assuming then you pass some of that cost saving onto your customers, you could deliver lower prices,” says Lander.

Story continues below advertisement

He added: “I just don’t think that’s what’s going to happen here, and if we look at Rogers’ tie-up with Shaw, it’s not like it’s led to lower prices for Rogers users or for Shaw users.”

Michael Osborne, chair of the Canadian Competition Law Practice at Cozen O’Connor says he agrees with Québecor’s claims about the ability to investment through the merger, but “it’s not going to increase choice,” and adds: “The rationales that I’m seeing don’t really make a lot of sense to me.”

Osborne also believes the merger would be challenged by the Competition Bureau because Freedom Mobile, which Québecor’s Videotron acquired as part of the Rogers-Shaw merger deal in 2023, would tip the scales beyond what the Competition Act allows.

“This merger, when you put together Telus’ market share of a little under 30 per cent and Freedom’s market share of just under 12 per cent, would definitely trip the threshold for a deemed substantial lessening or prevention of competition,” he says.

source

We are passionate about showcasing everything that makes the West Island unique—from its picturesque neighborhoods and local events to the entrepreneurs and businesses that keep the area thriving.