The Quebec man discovered not criminally liable for killing two youngsters after he drove a metropolis bus right into a Montreal-area daycare has been labelled a high-risk accused, a designation that can prohibit his actions whereas he’s detained at a psychiatric hospital.
On Monday, Superior Court docket Justice Éric Downs additionally upheld the constitutionality of a piece of the Felony Code that allows offenders discovered not criminally accountable due to a psychological dysfunction to be labelled “high-risk,” rejecting arguments from the defence that the standing reinforces stereotypes towards the mentally sick.
Final April, Downs dominated that Pierre Ny St-Amand, 54, was not criminally liable for the assault as a result of the previous metropolis bus driver had possible been in psychosis when he crashed the car right into a daycare in Laval, Que., Montreal’s northern suburb. The crash killed four-year-old Jacob Gauthier and a five-year-old woman named Maëva, whose household identify is roofed by a publication ban on the request of her dad and mom. Six different youngsters have been injured.
“The courtroom grants the prosecutor’s request: it designates the accused as high-risk underneath the Felony Code,” Downs mentioned on the Laval courthouse.
Get day by day Nationwide information
Get day by day Canada information delivered to your inbox so you may by no means miss the day’s prime tales.
“There’s a marked chance that the accused will use violence in a way that endangers the life or security of one other particular person … the acts that gave rise to the offences are of such a brutal nature that there’s a threat of great bodily or psychological hurt to a different particular person.”
The high-risk standing prevents St-Amand from leaving the psychiatric hospital the place he’s being detained apart from medical causes or for the needs of his therapy. It additionally limits the choices that the province’s psychological well being evaluate board could make in his case. Any modifications to his therapy plan or to the restrictions of his actions would must be put earlier than the Quebec Superior Court docket.
St-Amand has maintained he doesn’t keep in mind what occurred on the day of the crash. He’ll stay detained on the Philippe-Pinel psychiatric hospital in Montreal.
The Crown had sought a high-risk standing for St-Amand, with prosecutors arguing that by requiring each the province’s psychological well being evaluate board and the Superior Court docket to observe the accused, there can be a two-step validation course of to make sure the correct selections are taken in his case.
St-Amand’s legal professionals, in the meantime, argued the standing was unconstitutional and bolstered stereotypes towards the mentally sick. That they had challenged the high-risk accused designation on grounds they violated three sections of the Canadian Constitution of Rights and Freedoms.
Story continues beneath commercial
In his 103-page ruling on Monday, Downs upheld the constitutionality of the designation, which was adopted by the federal authorities in 2014 to make sure public security. The designation is outstanding and takes into consideration numerous elements together with professional opinions and judicial discretion.
The high-risk label “is non permanent and revocable as soon as the authorized circumstances are met,” Downs mentioned, including whereas he discovered no violation of constitutional rights within the case, “the courtroom stays conscious that it is a restrictive regime for the rights of sure defendants discovered not criminally accountable.”
Downs additionally famous that St-Amand has proven “modest” progress not too long ago. “It additionally seems that he has the capability to ultimately adhere to a strict therapy plan. Given his continued dedication to this course of, the courtroom encourages him to persevere in his therapy so as to meet the aims of the medical group.”
St-Amand was born in Cambodia in 1972, shortly earlier than the Khmer Rouge started a brutal rule that’s blamed for the deaths of 1.7 million individuals. Each his dad and mom died within the battle, and he doesn’t know his actual surname or birthday. In 1982, he was despatched to Canada by a humanitarian company and adopted by a Quebec household.
© 2026 The Canadian Press