Quebec’s Court docket of Enchantment has ordered a brand new trial for a person convicted of killing two people and injuring 5 others with a sword on Halloween night time in Quebec Metropolis in 2020.
A jury had discovered Carl Girouard guilty on two counts of first-degree homicide and 5 counts of tried homicide in 2022, and he was sentenced to life in jail with out the potential for parole for 25 years.
However the Court docket of Enchantment says the trial decide did not correctly inform jurors that they might not decide Girouard’s innocence or guilt primarily based on the very fact he remained silent throughout his police interrogation.
Get breaking Nationwide information
Get breaking Canada information delivered to your inbox because it occurs so you will not miss a trending story.
Girouard had admitted to the crimes however his lawyer Pierre Gagnon had argued his shopper was not criminally accountable due to a psychological dysfunction.
In his attraction, Gagnon argued that the Crown tried to make use of Girouard’s silence throughout his interrogation to ascertain that the accused was conscious of what was occurring and in the end had management over himself.
A panel of three Court docket of Enchantment judges agreed, saying the failure of the trial decide to correctly instruct jurors was grounds for a brand new trial.
The justices stated Grenier ought to have offered the 11 jurors with “a selected instruction stating that no inference of guilt might be drawn from the appellant’s train of his proper to stay silent.”
Girouard murdered Francois Duchesne, 56, a museum worker, and Suzanne Clermont, 61, a hairdresser, and injured 5 others within the Halloween night time assault. The trial heard Girouard drove from his dwelling north of Montreal with a Japanese-style sword known as a katana, which had a 76.9-centimeter blade. Carrying black jogging pants, black leather-based boots, a short-sleeved kimono and a black masks, Girouard proceeded to assault folks he got here throughout on the road, beginning in entrance of Le Chateau Frontenac lodge, within the metropolis’s historic quarter.
The Crown had argued the assaults have been premeditated and Girouard knew proper from mistaken. The jury had in the end agreed, figuring out he had intention to kill.
© 2026 The Canadian Press