Many urban neighborhoods have untapped potential for integration into agricultural production systems, energy production and carbon footprint reduction, according to a case study by two researchers from Concordia University.
They analyzed the real estate framework and open spaces of the Pointe-Saint-Charles district in southwest Montreal, concluding that more judicious urban space planning would allow for the annual production of 407 tonnes of diverse food crops, which would meet approximately 30 per cent of local demand.
On the energy side, the installation of solar panels could meet 14 per cent of the energy needs of the buildings in the district, while green roofs or greenhouses installed on the roof would reduce heating and air conditioning needs by acting as an additional layer of insulation on the roofs.
In the case of carbon footprint, the researchers’ model estimates that local agricultural production would reduce food transportation emissions by 96 per cent. However, the electricity consumed by greenhouses must be added to this figure.
Energy above the parking lots
How was this result achieved? The choice of Pointe-Saint-Charles wasn’t random, explains researcher Caroline Hachem-Vermette, from the Department of Building, Civil and Environmental Engineering. “Pointe-Saint-Charles truly combines residential, commercial, and industrial buildings with large roof areas, as well as underutilized land and parking lots. We also found a significant amount of urban agriculture activity and good access to public transportation. All of these factors make it a good pilot neighbourhood.”
The model under study proposes using rooftops for greenhouses, green spaces, or solar panels, depending on the building type, and converting vacant lots into agricultural growing areas. For parking lots, an original, simple, yet rarely used idea is also put forward: installing solar panels above these spaces to generate electricity without reducing their capacity. Otherwise, the researcher argues, “it’s a completely wasted space, a space that’s very bad for the environment.”
Finally, it is suggested that the various developments be organized to allow for the collection of rainwater to irrigate new growing spaces on rooftops, in greenhouses, and on vacant lots. Rainwater harvesting systems not only provide irrigation, but are also “a solution that can be well-suited to reducing runoff or mitigating flooding during heavy rainfall, for example.”
Redevelop rather than demolish
In the case of rooftops, Pointe-Saint-Charles has several aging, obsolete, and energy-inefficient industrial buildings. These buildings are too often seen as simply there to be demolished to make way for new construction, when they could be useful, especially, as Hachem-Vermette points out, since using these rooftops is more environmentally friendly and less expensive: “The costs of developing rooftops are certainly much lower than demolition and reconstruction. But there’s also the carbon footprint because demolishing and building means investing in new materials and sending all the old materials to the landfill, and that generates a lot of carbon.”
The ultimate goal, she says, is to integrate food, energy, and water into a single system. “Instead of trying to optimize each system in isolation, we’re looking at how they can work together to increase local resource self-sufficiency while reducing carbon emissions.”
The study divided Pointe-Saint-Charles into 91 neighbourhood units and evaluated three scenarios: maintaining the status quo; implementing interventions as described above; and a third option that would add a food-sharing network between neighbouring units, connecting them with food produced in one of them. Local grocery stores could then serve as distribution points, allowing residents to access food within a 15-minute walk.
Development on a human scale
“What’s really interesting here,” argues Hachem-Vermette, “is treating the different parts of the district as complementary. For example, some units have greater production potential while others have greater needs. So, the surpluses are redistributed to improve overall performance.”
As an added bonus, such an approach would help preserve the identity of the neighborhood and the continuity of the urban fabric, she said, thus responding to another imperative increasingly demanded by the population, that of development “on a human scale”.
The model presented in the study could very well be used in other neighborhoods. Caroline Hachem-Vermette notes that the Saint-Henri neighborhood offers essentially the same possibilities, but it is not the only one: “(The model) can easily be transferred to other neighborhoods or regions, but the most important thing is the methodology. So, in another city or even a village, for example, the analysis must be redone based on the local context, such as the climate, the types of buildings, the population, rainfall, and solar potential. The most important thing is the available surface area.”
For now, she says, they’re only at the modeling stage. “But I really hope this research can attract the attention of the city and other local stakeholders so we can open up this kind of discussion. If we can move from modeling to demonstration, that’s what will really capture people’s attention. How can we transform our neighborhood to become more productive and more vibrant? And it’s not necessary to transform the entire neighborhood all at once. We could start, for example, with a few pilot projects, then measure their performance and then gradually develop the approach.”
–This report by La Presse Canadienne was translated by CityNews




